Explore the Motion
Procedural History
CASE HISTORY AND PRIOR PROCEEDINGS
Last Revised • July 2, 2026
This section summarizes the procedural history of the Lyle C. May case, from the original capital trial through direct appeal, post-conviction litigation, and the proceedings leading to the Supplemental Motion for Appropriate Relief. The materials below provide a chronological overview of the case and the major legal developments that preceded the current proceedings.
Browse This Section
01Trial and Convictions
Overview of the Defendant's 1999 capital trial, convictions, and death sentences imposed by the Buncombe County Superior Court.
Direct Appeal
Review of the direct appeal to the North Carolina Supreme Court and the subsequent petition for certiorari to the United States Supreme Court.
Post-Conviction Proceedings
Summary of the Defendant's Motion for Appropriate Relief, evidentiary hearing, and additional post-conviction filings.
Current Procedural Posture
Overview of the pending post-conviction proceedings that provide the context for the Supplemental Motion.
Return to Explore the Motion
Continue browsing the remaining sections of the Supplemental Motion.