Repository Collection 03

Sworn Statement of APD Officer
Judy A. Hensley

GOVERNMENT RECORD ENTRY

Last Revised • July 6, 2026

This Source Verification Page documents the sworn statement of Asheville Police Department Officer Judy A. Hensley prepared during the investigation of the murders for which Lyle May was convicted. The statement records Officer Hensley's observations of the Defendant following his arrest and prior to his interrogation. The Supplemental Motion relies upon this statement to document the circumstances surrounding the Defendant's detention, physical condition, and custodial status before questioning.


Related SMAR Citation

“[Sworn Statement by APD Officer Judy Hensley]”


Source Title

Sworn Statement of APD Officer Judy A. Hensley


Date

July 10, 1997


Source Location

Defense Discovery — Not Released to the Public


Verification Source

Sworn Statement of APD Officer Judy A. Hensley


Highlighted Pages

1 - 2


Referenced in the Supplemental Motion

Page: 25, Paragraph: 42 (Also seen on Page: 32, 37, Paragraph: 55, 71)


Source Status

✔ Original sworn statement obtained and reviewed

✔ Relevant passages highlighted

X Not a publicly available source

✔ Included within the Source Verification Archive


Cited to Support

May's allegation that following his arrest, the Defendant was transported to the Asheville Police Department and held for several hours prior to interrogation by Detectives Judy Romick and Mike Downing. The sworn statement of APD Officer Judy Hensley is cited to establish that the Defendant was placed in an interview room, appeared tired, repeatedly attempted to sleep, and was kept awake while awaiting questioning by investigators. May relies upon this statement to support his claim that the Defendant was in continuous police custody, was not free to leave, and remained under police control for several hours before his interrogation. May further cites this source to document Officer Hensley's observations of the Defendant's condition prior to questioning and to support his allegation that Officer Hensley was not called as a witness during either the suppression hearing or trial. Judy Hensley also witnessed Detective Judy Romick prepare a written statement for Darrell Godfrey after he indicated that he did not write very well. After Detective Romick finished writing the statement for Godfrey, she then read it back to him, obtained his agreement with its contents, and Officer Hensley signed as a witness to the statement.


Supporting Documents

Highlighted Research Copy

Working research copy containing the highlighted passages cited in the Supplemental Motion.

View PDF →


Continue Your Research

Return to Statement of Facts C

Continue browsing the sources cited throughout Statement of Facts C.

Browse Sources →

Return to Source Verification Archive

Return to the main Source Verification Archive and explore additional sections of the Supplemental Motion.

Browse Archive →